Film Threat archive logo


By Rick Kisonak | April 24, 2013

It’s not every director who can make the future feel old hat but Joseph Kosinski (Tron: Legacy) definitely has the knack. This may well be his defining quality as a filmmaker.

In Oblivion we spend two hours plus in the year 2077 on a post-apocalyptic corner of the Earth in the company of computer-generated drones, super-sized space craft and a mechanic who lives in a Jetsonesque mansion 3000 feet in the air. Not a single minute seems like something we haven’t seen countless times before.

The mechanic, of course, is played by Tom Cruise, an action major who minors in science fiction. He can make a perfectly serviceable sci fi film. It just needs to be made with Steven Spielberg (Minority Report, War of the Worlds). Just one of Oblivion’s shortcomings is that it was not.

Oh-I just thought of another quality that distinguishes Kosinski: crazy, lottery winning-level luck. The story behind this movie is a million times more mindbending than anything in it.

In 1999 he graduated from the Columbia Graduate School of Architecture and subsequently taught there. His specialty? 3-D modeling. Realizing architecture wasn’t what he wanted to do, he moved to LA in 2005 and began writing a graphic novel entitled-you guessed it-Oblivion. While he looked for a publisher (none was ever found), he put his expertise in digital design to use as a director of cutting-edge TV spots.

Sounds like a sad story, right? Struggling writer can’t sell his work so sells out to pay the rent. Not in Kosinksi’s case. The next thing he knew, he started winning awards for his commercials and, get this, out of nowhere, Disney not only bought the film rights to his unpublished comic book but in 2007 handed him $170 million to direct a 3-D sequel to the 1982 cult hit Tron. The movie wasn’t released until 2010 so I’m guessing he spent years wondering whether he was secretly being taped for an episode of Punk’d.

Audiences, on the other hand, haven’t been so lucky. Particularly in the case of the filmmaker’s latest. Rewritten by William Monahan and then rewritten again by Karl Gajdusek, Oblivion proves less an original dystopian vision than a collection of motifs, twists and images lifted from decades of dystopian fare. If there’s a fresh concept here, I managed to miss it.

Cruise plays the last man on Earth. At least that’s what his Jack Harper has been programmed to believe by a generic Big Brother-type world order. A war between humans and space invaders has left the planet uninhabitable and the remainder of the race has decamped to a space station in preparation for a move to one of Saturn’s moons. He lives with a state-assigned girlfriend (Andrea Riseborough) and maintains a fleet of machines which guard what’s left of the world from further attack.

Except nothing is as it seems and virtually everything that happens already happened far more intriguingly in far better films. You know a picture’s derivative when a list of titles in the same genre technically constitutes a spoiler-Blade Runner, Independence Day, The Matrix, Moon, Planet of the Apes, Star Wars, Wall-E, 2001. It’s not so much that they provide the picture’s DNA as that Kosinski uses them as his personal cinematic ATM.

I won’t go into the story further. It has few enough surprises. I don’t want to ruin the only ones it does offer- namely what parts of which movies Kosinski will borrow and when. Prepare for some serious deja vu.

The consensus seems to be: pretentious, overly ponderous plot; snappy visuals courtesy of cinematographer Claudio Miranda, who just won an Oscar for his work on Life of Pi, and I think that’s pretty much on the money. Though, with $160 million to blow on CGI, it’s surprising Oblivion proves less a feast than a snack for the eyes.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Join our Film Threat Newsletter

Newsletter Icon