The Midnight Ride of Jonathan Luna | Film Threat
The Midnight Ride of Jonathan Luna Image

The Midnight Ride of Jonathan Luna

By Benjamin Franz | November 19, 2026

An update on Dan Cohen’s 2022 film, The Midnight Ride of Jonathan Luna, details the third murder of a federal prosecutor. Jonathan Luna was, by all accounts, an upstanding human being and an excellent counselor. December 2003, Luna was found dead in a shallow creek outside Lancaster, PA. He had been stabbed 36 times and seemingly drowned. The Midnight Ride of Jonathan Luna seeks to detail the conspiracy to hide these details for the better part of 21 years.

No profile of a person is complete without a review of his or her upbringing. In The Midnight Ride of Jonathan Luna, we learn Luna was a product of the South Bronx. A smart kid, Luna was enrolled at a Magnet school in Hell’s Kitchen. As we learn from one of his classmates, Andre Davis, Jonathan was of strong moral character and unimpeachable in his honesty. Clearly, this is the sort of person who would present a great threat to entrenched government officials with strong partisan tendencies. This is the exact personality type you find in U.S. Attorney offices. So it was with the Maryland US Attorney. Thomas DiBiagio, a Bush appointee, was strongly and stridently partisan. It is relayed in The Midnight Ride of Jonathan Luna that Luna and DiBiagio clashed on politics frequently. As Dan Cohen’s reenactment progresses, we see several people with possible, but not definitive, motives to harm Jonathan Luna.

A reenactment of Jonathan Luna in court in The Midnight Ride of Jonathan Luna.

“December 2003, Luna was found dead in a shallow creek outside Lancaster, PA.”

The Midnight Ride of Jonathan Luna’s main drama centers around a lawsuit that occurred in the summer and fall of 2003. Three men were arrested by the FBI for drug charges. One of them, Alvin Jones, may have committed a murder that was connected to this as well. Alvin Jones, it is inferred, must have had a guardian angel high up in the Federal government, because the entire time this trial proceeds, the Defense as well as FBI operatives are working to eliminate the murder charge from Jones. That fateful day in December, Luna informs the judge he and the defense have come to a settlement, and he would work through the night to prepare it. We know from transcripts reenacted in The Midnight Ride of Jonathan Luna that Luna did not wish to wipe the murder charge from Alvin Jones. As the film relates, he worked on the terms long into the night. At 11:30 pm, he drove off to Pennsylvania, where he and his family lived. And that, as they say, was that for Jonathan Luna.

I found The Midnight Ride of Jonathan Luna to be striking in several ways. First, we learn that local police in Central Pennsylvania colluded with the FBI to keep the records of what actually happened to Jonathan Luna sealed until 2025. Then, Gail Gibson, a journalist employed by the Baltimore Sun, started dropping a rumor in her articles and op-eds that Jonathan Luna committed suicide. Further, that because he was carrying 25,000 dollars in debt, he was trying to find shady ways to cover it. Andre Davis and Reggie Shuford confirm for us that it was just not possible. Luna was of upstanding moral character. He would never have done anything suspicious. He was a Paladin for good. Finally, what was most striking is that no one will ever, apparently, be held to account for this murder. All we know is that it happened in 2003, and that no one seems to be the responsible party for stabbing Luna 36 times and drowning him in a shallow creek.

The Midnight Ride of Jonathan Luna is a mesmerizing and puzzling work of art. This one deserves to be seen by anyone who loves a good unsolved mystery. Seek it out where it streams.

For screening information, visit the The Midnight Ride of Jonathan Luna official website.

The Midnight Ride of Jonathan Luna (2026)

Directed and Written: Dan Cohen

Starring: Andre Davis, Reggie Shuford, Jacabed Rodriguez Coss, William Keiling, etc.

Movie score: 7.5/10

The Midnight Ride of Jonathan Luna Image

"…a mesmerizing and puzzling work of art..."

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Join our Film Threat Newsletter

Newsletter Icon