I Play Rocky | Film Threat
I Play Rocky Image

I Play Rocky

By Rick Hong | November 19, 2026

NOW IN THEATERS! Everyone on the planet knows Sylvester Stallone, and just about everyone knows the character of “Rocky.” What most people don’t know is how closely the film mirrors Stallone’s real underdog story: an aspiring actor with few opportunities who ended up writing a movie for himself. I Play Rocky gives audiences that story.

Before there was Sylvester Stallone (Anthony Ippolito), there was Mike Stallone, an actor auditioning in New York, and that’s where our film begins. He lives in a rat hole and can barely make rent. To make matters worse, when an audition comes up and he asks for time off from work, he’s told “No,” so he quits, which leaves him homeless. He finds a pup scrounging for food near some dumpsters, adopts him, and names him “Butkus.” Eventually, Stallone lands a job at a movie theatre, where he meets Sasha (AnnaSophia Robb), who becomes his wife. She tells him she likes him better as “Sylvester,” his real name, rather than “Mike,” and that if acting roles aren’t coming his way, he should write a film for himself.

“…inspired by a boxing match that he watches at a local bar, Stallone then writes Rocky in just three days.”

After moving to Los Angeles in search of better opportunities, Stallone gets a general meeting with producers Irwin Winkler (P.J. Byrne) and Bob Chartoff (Toby Kebbell). Their assistant gets his screenplay, Paradise Alley, slipped to them, and the producers are impressed enough to want to work with him. Unfortunately, the project goes nowhere at the time (although it eventually gets made). However, inspired by a boxing match that he watches at a local bar, Stallone then writes Rocky in just three days. When he presents the first draft to the producers, that’s when the real fun begins.

Peter Farrelly directs, bringing the same sensibility and tone he brought to Green Book. There’s lightheartedness and fun here, because we all know how the story really ends; the movie gets made, and Stallone becomes an ’80s action icon.

What really stands out is the casting. You can’t have this movie without finding the perfect Stallone, and Anthony Ippolito is a true embodiment of the real-life man, nailing the voice and mannerisms and bulking up for the part. At a recent reception, he shared with me that he ate every two hours and ingested 225 grams of protein daily. Casting director Rick Montgomery was also there and said that when he first got the call, he hesitated because Ippolito had just played Al Pacino in The Offer, and he worried the actor lacked the stature. Film Threat’s very own Chris Gore saw Ippolito’s audition on the actor’s phone and was elated.

“I Play Rocky is being pushed this awards season, and it deserves to be.”

AnnaSophia Robb, who has been acting since childhood, is another highlight. I felt this was her 2.0, and I was able to tell her that in person. She commands the screen as much as Ippolito does, and you can see how her character is the driving force as Stallone’s wife; she encourages him and gives him the notes that make the Rocky screenplay whole. Writer Peter Gamble shared that a script note from his manager was simply to think about Amy Adams in The Fighter.

The supporting actors, P.J. Byrne, Toby Kebbell, Jay Duplass, and Tracy Letts, are key components. Duplass plays director John Avildsen, who shares Stallone’s vision with a no-nonsense approach. Byrne and Kebbell, as the two producers who keep trying to get the project going, and Letts, as the studio executive who will stop at nothing to get Stallone thrown off it, deliver plenty of good laughs and memorable moments.

I Play Rocky is being pushed this awards season, and it deserves to be. There are many heavy films that drag on and leave you depressed or underwhelmed. I told Gamble that, among my peers, this is the one that has won everyone over as the feel-good movie of the season, and it brought tears to his eyes.

I Play Rocky (2026)

Directed: Peter Farrelly

Written: Peter Gamble

Starring: Anthony Ippolito, AnnaSophia Robb, Matt Dillon, Toby Kebbell, P.J. Byrne, Jay Duplass, Tracy Letts, etc.

Movie score: 9/10

I Play Rocky Image

"…He lives in a rat hole and can barely make rent."

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Join our Film Threat Newsletter

Newsletter Icon