THE WILD BUNCH FILM FESTIVAL 2026 REVIEW! Bullet-ridden Tombstone goes under the knife in the exceptionally scripted western bio-pic Dr. Goodfellow, written by Manuela Schneider, who directed the film with the help of Robert Craighead. Dr. George Emery Goodfellow (Robert Craighead) is the local sawbones in Tombstone, where he is endlessly busy patching up folk that done shot each other for no dang reason. Dr. Goodfellow cares little for the reason for the gunplay, as he is more concerned with resolving the consequences. His steadfast fight against death has resulted in several innovations, with bullet-wound surgeries being developed out of necessity, robbing the Boot Hill cemetery of new residents. Then one day, there is a massive shootout between the Earps and the Clantons at the O.K. Corral, so the doctor gets busy patching up both sides. Ike Clanton (Terry Ike Clanton) begs Dr. Goodfellow to save his boys, but they are shot so badly that there is nothing to be done.
The doctor also treats Doc Holliday (Chris James Rivera), who will survive well enough so that he can continue to drink himself to death. There is an uproar in Tombstone over what really happened at the O.K. Corral, with Dr. Goodfellow being called to testify at the trial of Wyatt Earp (Jimmy Greene), and his brothers Virgil (Jim Heffel), and Morgan (Dylan Hobbs). Prosecutor Price (Craig Hensley) makes a case that the Clantons had surrendered to Marshal Earp and his deputies, but were shot down in cold blood anyway. Dr. Goodfellow remains neutral, going over the clinical findings of the wounds, which pointed to gunplay instead of execution. Judge Spicer (Peter Sherayko) finds the Earp brothers not guilty, with many in Tombstone furious over the verdict. A lot of hatred is directed at the doctor, as it was his testimony that tipped the scales. Dr. Goodfellow claims neutrality, but soon finds that while he sits on the fence, a burning Hell of bloodshed has sprung up on all sides in Tombstone…
“Then one day, there is a massive shoot-out between the Earps and the Clantons at the O.K. Corral, so the doctor gets busy patching up both sides.”
Dr. Goodfellow is a film about Tombstone that is like no other. My main background on Tombstone, before I moved out to the territory myself, was shaped by Ford’s My Darling Clementine and, of course, Tombstone. So I had no idea how deep the controversy over the gunfight at the O.K. Corral went, nor did I know that it still sits smoldering, like an underground lake of fire. So I got a serious schooling from Dr. Goodfellow, who, like the good doctor himself, feigns neutrality, despite obviously landing on one side of the argument. Schneider, simply by highlighting the courtroom drama so early in the picture, brings the Clanton family’s argument about who the real villains were in that fight. Schneider goes so far as to cast a blood relative of Ike Clanton to play Ike Clanton, which is wild beyond belief. Yes, it shows both sides, but the story also shows that the truth about the Earps is still out there.
Some of the acting in Dr. Goodfellow is truly magnificent. With mad respect paid to Mature and Kilmer, Chris James Rivera delivers the finest Doc Holliday performance of the 21st century. He has that haunted quality Mature had, while also sporting a flagrant death wish like Kilmer. But Rivera brings that quality all the other Hollidays have been missing: he looks like a dentist with a gun. Not a rock star, not a movie star, but a dentist who is sick. It is this vulnerability that Rivera uses to extend Doc’s fangs of defiance. Greene is a much more menacing Wyatt Earp than we usually get, which makes his dark turn a real treat. Craighead is pitch-perfect throughout, with each line delivery a masterclass in Old West diction. Craighead has the knack for making the audience go nuts over an important historical figure they didn’t know existed until a minute ago.

Promotional art of Terry Ike Clanton as Ike Clanton for a Dr. Goodfellow meet and greet in Prescott.
“…Chris James Rivera delivers the finest Doc Holliday performance of the 21st century.”
Dr. Goodfellow is by no means a perfect picture. While some of the performances are blue chip, some of the other acting is moose chip. Also, the AI-like digital imagery used to recreate Old West buildings plain old sucks. But the costumes by Karin McKechnie are masterworks in Western fashion, a joy to behold when framed by the world-class set design by none other than Terry Ike Clanton. But towering over it all, like an endless windstorm, is the utterly brilliant screenplay by Schneider. The richness of how deeply the historical details are presented is show-stopping; you will learn, I mean it. Schneider also manages an impressive tug of war within the biopic structure, as the presentation of the doctor’s life cannot escape the black hole the O.K. Corral ripped open. She really puts a stethoscope over the whole Tombstone catastrophe, letting it ring out loud.
Dr. Goodfellow is a film set in a bygone era that is crafted with some of the best bygone-era methods. I am talking about Schneider’s penchant for Hollywood Golden Age screenwriting, with much of the action caught in tapestries of dialogue. It is a very old-school way of writing a movie, and it is exactly what audiences want right now. The modern way to relax is to have a movie on in the background while you flip through videos on your phone. The more descriptive the audio, the better, as that allows a viewer to somewhat follow the action while glued to their poptart. It requires repetition without redundancy; verbosity without windbagging, lost arts which Schneider wields with ease. A smart streamer would hire her to script-doctor every original film they do, as she has what the crowds want. Dr. Goodfellow is brimming with excellence throughout, and you can follow it while living your life.
Dr. Goodfellow screened at the 2026 The Wild Bunch Film Festival.
"…it is exactly what audience's want right now."